By Matt Reichert
Change is one of the few constants in human experience (along with death and taxes). Cultures shift, technologies evolve and values are debated and redefined. Amid all this adaptation, the Catholic Church seems to stand as a witness to permanence — a 2,000-year-old community rooted in the unchanging truth of Jesus Christ. And yet, the Church is also alive, dynamic and always in need of renewal.
The Catholic view of change is not one of fear or resistance. Rather, it is a vision grounded in conversion, discernment and fidelity. The Church believes that authentic change does not mean abandoning her foundations but allowing the Holy Spirit to draw her ever closer to Christ and her mission.
A key expression of this vision is found in the Vatican’s 2020 instruction “The Pastoral Conversion of the Parish Community in the Service of the Evangelizing Mission of the Church.” This document, issued by the Congregation for the Clergy, articulates how the Church understands change — not as rupture or innovation for its own sake, but as the fruit of pastoral conversion and missionary renewal.
These are all important considerations for us here in the Diocese of St. Cloud as we journey together through the process of pastoral planning. As we enter the next phase of our planning initiative, let’s explore the interplay between permanence and conversion, both for ourselves and our parish communities.
The foundation: An unchanging truth
At the heart of Catholic teaching lies the conviction that divine revelation — God’s self-communication in Jesus Christ — is complete and definitive. As the Letter to the Hebrews proclaims, “Jesus Christ is the same yesterday, today, and forever” (Hebrews 13:8). The Deposit of Faith (Depositum Fidei), which includes all that God has revealed through Scripture and Tradition, is entrusted to the Church to be faithfully guarded and transmitted (Dei Verbum, 10).
The Church cannot alter this revelation; she can only deepen her understanding of it. The Catechism of the Catholic Church explains, “The Christian faith cannot accept ‘revelations’ that claim to surpass or correct the Revelation of which Christ is the fulfillment” (CCC 66).
serves the Church as an educator, author, coach
and consultant. He works for the Catholic Leadership
Institute and resides in
Richmond with his family.
Pope St. John Paul II expressed this enduring truth in “Veritatis Splendor”: “The Church’s moral teaching is not an arbitrary imposition; it is a reflection of the truth of the human person revealed in Christ.” In other words, truth itself does not change — but our hearts must be continually converted to it.
The growth of understanding: Development, not replacement
While the truths of faith do not change, our understanding of them can and must grow. St. John Henry Newman, proclaimed a doctor of the Church by Pope Leo XIV on Nov. 1, 2025, described this process in his classic work, “An Essay on the Development of Christian Doctrine,” “In a higher world it is otherwise, but here below, to live is to change, and to be perfect is to have changed often.”
The Second Vatican Council reaffirmed this insight, “The Tradition that comes from the apostles makes progress in the Church, with the help of the Holy Spirit. There is a growth in insight into the realities and words that are being passed on” (Dei Verbum, 8).
This means that doctrine does not evolve in its essence, but our comprehension of it matures through prayer, study and experience. Over the centuries, this dynamic has guided the Church’s teaching — from the early Christological debates of the Councils to social encyclicals like “Rerum Novarum” and “Laudato Si’,” which applied perennial moral principles to the questions of industrialization and ecology.
Development, in the Catholic sense, is not innovation detached from truth; it is growth rooted in fidelity. It allows the Church to speak the eternal Word of God in a language each generation can understand.
The nature of true change: Conversion, not innovation
The Church’s understanding of change is captured by a single word: conversion. In “The Pastoral Conversion of the Parish Community,” the Congregation for the Clergy makes clear that the transformation the Church seeks is first and foremost spiritual. “Pastoral conversion,” it says, “is not simply about organizational restructuring, but about an interior transformation that leads to renewed missionary zeal.”
This is a crucial distinction. The Church does not change to keep up with the world; she changes to remain faithful to her mission in the world. True change begins not in structures or strategies but in hearts — when believers allow the Holy Spirit to renew their encounter with Christ and inspire them to share that encounter with others.
“The parish is not an outdated institution,” the document insists, “because it possesses great flexibility.” What needs reform, therefore, is not the essence of the parish but its energy, its missionary outlook. The call to “pastoral conversion”
is a call to move from maintenance to mission, from passive reception to active discipleship.
Change in the service of mission
Every authentic reform in the Church serves one goal: evangelization. The Pastoral Conversion document situates all change in the context of the Church’s missionary identity: “The reform of parish structures should be put in the context of missionary conversion.”
The parish is not simply an administrative unit but “a community of communities,” a living cell in the Body of Christ that proclaims the Gospel to its surroundings. The instruction calls for creativity in responding to changing circumstances — urbanization, mobility, digital culture — without losing sight of the parish’s core purpose: to be a home of the Word, the Eucharist and charity.
This perspective echoes Pope Francis’s call in “Evangelii Gaudium,” “The Church is called to be permanently in a state of mission.” Change, when animated by mission, becomes a sign of vitality rather than instability. The Spirit leads the Church not into confusion but into new forms of witness.
The parish as a living organism
In one of its most evocative passages, the Pastoral Conversion document describes the parish as a “living organism” capable of adaptation and growth. A living organism remains itself while continually changing — responding to new needs, regenerating what has grown weak and healing what has been wounded.
This image reveals the Church’s theology of continuity. A living Church is not static; she breathes with the life of the Spirit. Change, in this sense, is not opposition to tradition but its proper expression. Tradition literally means “to hand on.” The Church hands on the faith by living it anew in each generation.
A healthy parish, therefore, is one that is rooted in the sacraments and Scripture yet responsive to the needs of the local community. It listens, accompanies and serves — always pointing beyond itself to Christ.
Discernment: Guarding authentic change
The Church’s openness to change is never uncritical. The same instruction warns against confusing pastoral creativity with mere innovation. “Pastoral conversion,” it says, “does not consist in the simple renewal of structures, but in the renewal of faith and of the Christian life itself.”
Authentic change always requires discernment — a careful listening to the Holy Spirit and to the lived reality of the people of God. Discernment protects the Church from two opposite errors: rigidity that resists renewal and relativism that compromises truth.
As St. Paul wrote, “Test everything; hold fast what is good” (1 Thessalonians 5:21). This process of discernment, guided by the Magisterium, ensures that change serves communion and holiness, not division or confusion.
Pope Benedict XVI expressed the same idea in “Caritas in Veritate,” “Truth preserves and expresses itself in love; to the extent that we detach ourselves from truth, we endanger authentic human development.” In short, change that is faithful must always be anchored in truth and charity together.
Change as hope and holiness
Ultimately, the Church’s vision of change is rooted in hope. Christians believe in a God who declares, “Behold, I make all things new” (Revelation 21:5). Change, when guided by grace, becomes a participation in God’s ongoing work of renewal in creation and in the Church.
The Pastoral Conversion of the Parish Community document reminds believers that the Church’s future depends not on perfect programs but on holy people. When parishes embrace conversion, they become places of encounter, community and mission — signs of God’s Kingdom in a restless world.
This is the deepest meaning of change in the Catholic tradition: transformation into holiness. The call is not merely to adjust structures or modernize language but to let Christ renew the Church from within. As the Catechism teaches, “Interior repentance is a radical reorientation of our whole life” (CCC 1431).
To remain faithful
The Catholic Church views change not as a break from her past, but as a deepening of her fidelity to Christ. The truth does not change, but the Church must continually be converted so that she can proclaim that truth more fully and live it more convincingly.
So, what does this mean for us in this moment of renewal in the Diocese of St. Cloud? The Pastoral Conversion of the Parish Community offers a blueprint for this renewal — calling every parish and believer to missionary discipleship, spiritual conversion and pastoral creativity. In doing so, it echoes the heart of the Gospel itself: change is not to be feared when it leads to love.
In a world where change often breeds anxiety, the Church offers a paradoxical comfort: we are called to change precisely because God does not. The unchanging Lord is always making his Church new — not by discarding what came before, but by perfecting it in holiness.
You speak of hope,change and an optimistic future. The elderly in small Minnesota towns do not see their churches closing as any of these. You are taking away their friends, communities ,outings and their homes of worship. Are you forgetting the worth of these people. ? You talk about mission, they are your mission. Stop making excuses, you wasted the money with all of your lawsuits. Now, buck up and keep these churches open.